The Impact Insider
Engagement best practices, tips, and trends.
Deepening engagement requires vigilance and perseverance.
Every Friday we help you dig deeper into developing a highly engaged workforce by delivering the industry’s top engagement information, inspiration, and impactful tips straight to your inbox.
Effective managers are made, not born
A cautionary tale of what NOT to do
Once upon a time, in the bustling city of Metropolis, there was a renowned firm called “Klein & Klein.” It was known far and wide for handling complex and high-stakes client business issues. Among the talented team of professionals, there was an exceptional associate named Alex, who had recently been promoted to the position of partner. However, there was one crucial factor that had been overlooked – Alex had never received any formal training on how to manage people.
As a partner, Alex was entrusted with leading a team of associates and business professionals. Unfortunately, the absence of managerial training became glaringly apparent, leading to a series of mismanagement blunders with far-reaching consequences.
One of the most impactful examples of mismanagement occurred when Alex failed to effectively delegate tasks. Without clear instructions and guidance, team members often found themselves overwhelmed or unsure of their responsibilities. As a result, the workload became imbalanced, leading to burnout and decreased morale. The associates, who were eager to prove themselves and contribute to the firm’s success, started feeling undervalued and disengaged, as their potential wasn’t being fully utilized. Consequently, the overall productivity of the team suffered, translating into missed deadlines and compromised client satisfaction.
Another instance of improper management arose from Alex’s poor communication skills. Rather than fostering open and transparent communication, Alex would often keep important information to themselves, assuming that team members were aware of the bigger picture. This lack of clarity and transparency caused confusion and misunderstandings, resulting in costly errors in documents and missed opportunities to address critical client concerns. The inability to effectively communicate ideas and expectations also resulted in a breakdown of trust within the team, as associates felt left in the dark, unable to seek guidance or provide valuable input.
Additionally, Alex struggled with recognizing and acknowledging the accomplishments and hard work of the team. Rather than offering praise and constructive feedback, Alex often overlooked the achievements of associates and rarely provided guidance for improvement. This lack of recognition and mentorship left team members feeling undervalued and demotivated. It sowed seeds of resentment and frustration, leading to increased turnover rates as talented team members sought opportunities where their skills and efforts would be appreciated.
The impacts of this improper management were far-reaching. The reputation of “Klein & Klein” began to suffer as client satisfaction declined due to missed deadlines, errors in work, and ineffective communication. Morale within the team plummeted, leading to a toxic work environment characterized by low engagement and high turnover rates. The firm’s profitability was significantly affected, as the cost of replacing and training new people increased.
This parable serves as a cautionary tale. It reminds us that being proficient in one’s individual role does not necessarily translate into effective management. Only through investing in the development of managerial capabilities can organizations ensure sustainable success and a harmonious workplace, where individuals can thrive and contribute their best.